Who Should Have Won the Best Actress Oscar for 1928-29?

If you’ve never looked at Wiley and Bona’s masterly reference work, Inside Oscar, you should. It’s the final word on exactly what occurred each year. Here is how they summed up Mary Pickford winning Best Actress for Coquette: the mystery was “how the Academy could possibly have given Best Actress to Mary Pickford in  a movie which nobody liked.”

The answer is simple: a tea party for the judges at Pickfair. More or less, a command performance, and the command was, “Gimme an Oscar.”

The Academy nominated several others:

The Barker 1928 Poster.jpg

Film buffs may be more intrigued by the fact that Yasujirō Ozu remade this movie as A Story of Floating Weeds (1934) and again as Floating Weeds (1959).

Then there’s Bessie Love in The Broadway Melody:


And Corinne Griffith in The Divine Lady:


The very first posthumous nomination came for Jeanne Eagels in The Letter (now more famous as the Bette Davis remake):

The Letter

The last official nominee was Ruth Chatterton in Madame X:

Madame X29.jpg

Here’s what I had to say about a few of these nominations from V. 1, WHO Won?!? An Irreverent Look at the Oscars, 1927-1943:

“Ruth Chatterton in Madame X, Corinne Griffith in The Divine Lady, and Bessie Love in The Broadway Melody aren’t worth an Oscar, thus removing them from consideration here. Having to sit through all three of their movies would make a good punishment for any detention hall in high school. Most of them are awkward, stiff, and worst of all, boring, especially when compared to the actresses the Academy didn’t even bother mentioning. Ruth Chatterton would have some other movies that aren’t so painful to watch, but the fallen woman melodrama Madame X isn’t one of them. Posturing, emoting, and faked sobbing on cue isn’t good acting (or good directing). Lucille Ball does a much better drunk on Vitameatavegamin commercials. I wish the Academy didn’t have this weakness for handing actresses the Oscar for endless crying and emotional wailing, but they do. Griffith plays Lady Hamilton, the love of Lord Nelson in England during the Napoleonic Wars (Laurence Olivier and Vivien Leigh would later cover the same story in That Hamilton Woman). Griffith is overacting much of the time, which is not uncommon in the pre-talkie era. Griffith’s performance isn’t as awful as others, but in a film about a great romance where the naval battles outshine the romance, Griffith has clearly not done her job (Marie Dressler is much more fun in the movie as her mother). Bessie Love has some sparkle at times in Broadway Melody, but not enough to overcome the rest of the boredom she inflicts.”

So who did the Academy ignore?

This amazing pair of eyes:

Renee Maria Falconetti never made another movie after The Passion of Joan of Arc, but Lillian Gish did, after proving once more her gifts in The Wind:

The Wind (1928).jpg

And then there’s the first truly great Greta Garbo film, A Woman of Affairs:

And then there’s Fay Wray, proving she could do more than scream around overbearing suitors with another overbearing suitor, Erich von Stroheim, in The Wedding March:

Theweddingmarch poster.jpg

See, Academy? Was it so hard to actually find great performances this year?

If you would like to make other suggestions, please do so below in the comments!

As always, I have much more to say in my book: http://www.amazon.com/dp/B00OPEELH0

And now, please vote!

One comment

  1. Jeanne Eagels’ performance in THE LETTER is one of the bravest, gutsiest, most (pardon the expression) balls-to-the-wall performances I have ever seen and should have won the Oscar instead of Pickford. I usually include this win for Pickford one of the biggest fallacies in Oscar history, along with THE GREAT ZIEGFELD winning over DODSWORTH, FAME winning the Original Score award over THE ELEPHANT MAN and FROZEN winning Animated Feature over THE WIND RISES.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s